Skip to content

Matthew

My feedback

1 result found

  1. 39 votes

    We're glad you're here

    Please sign in to leave feedback

    Signed in as (Sign out)

    We’ll send you updates on this idea

    Matthew supported this idea  · 
    An error occurred while saving the comment
    Matthew commented  · 

    Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yE3DE9QYNxw. There are two versions, I think this one is best, having the most mental music and editing, I must say.

    - The dialogue is dubbed into English in extremely awkward ways to match the French dialogue pace. The best moment is at about 36:54 in the youtube video, where the Martian (whose name translates to "Poo Flower" in English, after having the kids speak into a universal translator of sorts) is talking to Frankie into the camera... and it's just... indescribable.
    - The editing is exquisitely bad. A shot of the cop car leaving Frankie's uncle's shop is used multiple times. Conversations are cut off and cut to another scene entirely. But it's not so terrible that it loses you. It's that perfect balance of valiant effort and awkward failure.
    - The special effects are lovably bad. The big unexplained matchstick which allows the holder of it to fly with a big light to obscure the crane and rope. The rope/antenna on the spaceship that keeps getting longer. The Martian's green spray paint jump-cut footsteps in the snow. The self-propelled-stomach-skating at the hockey game.
    - The writing and acting and everything like the costume of the Martian, the villagers and cops, it all adds up to a really nicely strange vibe that's somehow endearing, but entirely mental. The sheriff guy breaks the fourth wall during a bad joke. The kids somehow steal the Christmas turkey and take it to the spaceship. They somehow steal a snowmobile and large snow plow tractor which underage Frankie then operates. So much great stuff.

    I saw this for the first time in England and it changed my life. I watch it every year. This would be perfect for riffing! I really hope you guys consider this!

Feedback and Knowledge Base