The first and third Creature from the Black Lagoon films!
You did "Revenge of the Creature" It would be awesome if you did the other two films of the Creature series. The third one is REALLY bad and has Jeff Morrow and Rex Reason from "This Island Earth" in it!!
Tamsin Parker commented
I made up a few riffs from the original, such as when the Creature first sees the girl, swims up to her and then swims away, I commented "D'ohh, that wasn't right, let me try it again."